Everything Star Wars

Tsunami

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
29,529
Likes
4,712
The secret identity of bad wizard wasn't too hard to guess. He is a bad dude, if a little too prone to monologuing
 

Uncle Menno

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
3,210
Likes
2,314
Acolyte Ep. 6. Two interesting pairs now: Qimir and Osha, Sol and Mae, with the former written more interestingly than the latter.

Lucas planted the seeds of Jedi hubris/arrogance by having the Jedi admit they never suspected Palpatine was a Sith, despite being around him constantly. Acolyte is really cultivating those seeds—fanbois be damned—and it’s turning out to be interesting.
 
Last edited:

Uncle Menno

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
3,210
Likes
2,314
Acolyte Ep. 7. This is the penultimate episode, so one hopes that the many story threads will converge coherently in Ep. 8.

Ep. 7 is a retelling of the events on Brendok that we saw in Ep. 3. The critical difference is that in Ep. 3, we saw them from the point of view of the Witches; now, we see them from the point of view of the Jedi. Critical details are filled in.

A fair amount of lore is relied upon, although the arguments I've seen that "So-and-so/such-and-such is NOT canon!!!" take me back to my Fundamentalist upbringing, with the endless and hate-filled arguments that "So-and-so/such-and-such is NOT Biblical!!!"

The world is always larger than our theories about it.
 

Uncle Menno

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
3,210
Likes
2,314
FiOS puked and died in the middle of the USA vs. Costa Rica soccer game last night, so I haven’t yet seen Ep. 8 of _Acolyte_.

So in the meantime, here’s a look at the kind of fervor, devotion, and ecstasy Luke Skywalker can evoke among the faithful.

These are fans reacting to Luke’s appearance in the final episode of _Mandalorian_ Season 2. Seeing these reactions helped me understand why Rian Johnson’s portrayal of Luke provoked such outrage: it was sacrilege, pure and simple.

[Plot points for the clip: the bad guy, Moff Gideon (Gian-Carlo Esposito) has kidnapped Baby Yoda/Grogu in order to try to steal/transfer his Force abilities. The good guys—Mando and his crew—track down and board Moff Gideon’s ship where Baby Yoda/Grogu is being held. Miff Gideon’s mechanized super-troopers corner the good guys on the bridge, where they are holding Gideon and the freed Baby Yoda. Just when all seems lost, a single X-wing fighter hoves into view.]

 
Last edited:

TStecker

Personal Assistant
Messages
75,600
Likes
6,756
Overall - C-, characters weren’t interesting, the story didn’t make alot of sense. The lead characters did nothing for me. Wake me when Star Wars gets it’s act together for the Mandalorian Movie
 

Tsunami

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
29,529
Likes
4,712
Overall - C-, characters weren’t interesting, the story didn’t make alot of sense. The lead characters did nothing for me. Wake me when Star Wars gets it’s act together for the Mandalorian Movie
Could be a long nap, Padawan.
 

Uncle Menno

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
3,210
Likes
2,314
Could be a long nap, Padawan.
Mebbe. Who knew that The Mandalorian's first two seasons were going to be as good as they were? And who saw Andor coming? No question that a lot of meh stuff came down the pike--even Coppola had a Godfather III--but who can say where the lightning will strike next?

Verizon tech replaced all of our hardware before the router/modem and we're working again. (The tech said, with a certain amount of disbelief, "You know this stuff was put in in 2008?") Maybe I'll get to watch Acolyte tonight.
 

TStecker

Personal Assistant
Messages
75,600
Likes
6,756
Mebbe. Who knew that The Mandalorian's first two seasons were going to be as good as they were? And who saw Andor coming? No question that a lot of meh stuff came down the pike--even Coppola had a Godfather III--but who can say where the lightning will strike next?

Verizon tech replaced all of our hardware before the router/modem and we're working again. (The tech said, with a certain amount of disbelief, "You know this stuff was put in in 2008?") Maybe I'll get to watch Acolyte tonight.
I like GF III. Had its problems, but a lot of good stuff too that’s worth remembering
 

Uncle Menno

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
3,210
Likes
2,314
Overall - C-, characters weren’t interesting, the story didn’t make alot of sense. The lead characters did nothing for me. Wake me when Star Wars gets it’s act together for the Mandalorian Movie
Finally got to see it. On the whole, it just didn’t feel completely baked. Given only what we see of the Jedi Order in these eight episodes, why would anyone ever think of them as the good guys? They’re arrogantly self-righteous liars on the one hand and appallingly naive about their own weaknesses on the other. And the traits we see are made so extreme that the narrative becomes almost incoherent.
 

Uncle Menno

Personal Assistant
Donator
Messages
3,210
Likes
2,314
Somebody named Sam Adams wrote about the Acolyte for Slate, although it popped up in my Yahoo feed. I like what he says, especially in his final paragraph:
"This is incredibly fertile terrain, edging up to the most radical rethinking of the core Star Wars mythology since The Last Jedi. But given the furor into which even a cursory mention of that movie still sends a noisy minority of fans, it’s not surprising that The Acolyte backs away in the end. After steering clear of the entanglements of lore, the finale works in a cameo that will be unintelligible to all but the most devoted followers, and ends with Vernestra turning to a familiar pair of fuzzy green ears for help. We’re back in the land of servicing fans rather than challenging them, and if all is not right with the world, at least Yoda is in the loop now. When it was a largely self-contained story, The Acolyte had the freedom to invent at will, to kill off or warp as many characters as it liked without worrying about their place in some future installment. But the moment it’s tied back into the larger universe, that freedom evaporates, and all that’s left is the feeling of a promise unfulfilled."
 
Top