"This is incredibly fertile terrain, edging up to the most radical rethinking of the core
Star Wars mythology since
The Last Jedi. But given the furor into which even a cursory mention of that movie still sends a noisy minority of fans, it’s not surprising that
The Acolyte backs away in the end. After steering clear of the entanglements of lore, the finale works in a
cameo that will be unintelligible to all but the most devoted followers, and ends with Vernestra turning to a familiar pair of fuzzy green ears for help. We’re back in the land of servicing fans rather than challenging them, and if all is not right with the world, at least Yoda is in the loop now. When it was a largely self-contained story,
The Acolyte had the freedom to invent at will, to kill off or warp as many characters as it liked without worrying about their place in some future installment. But the moment it’s tied back into the larger universe, that freedom evaporates, and all that’s left is the feeling of a promise unfulfilled."